The Dating of Food Vessels and Urns in Ireland, by A.L. Brindley
National University of Ireland, Galway 2007, Bronze
Age Studies 7, 392pp, 164 figs, 75 tabs hb ISBN 9534620-206 (€ 40)
This excellently produced book provides a wealth of contextual and chronological
data for the Irish Early Bronze Age. It is based on a large corpus of pottery and
an impressive body of radiocarbon dates and it is largely possible due to the comparatively
recent breakthrough in the dating of cremated bone. This volume almost represents
Anna Brindley’s life’s work, certainly a labour of love, and also represents a somewhat
considerable financial investment in Irish archaeology in the terms of the number
of radiocarbon dates. It is an excellent companion to Waddell (1990) and O Riordain
& Waddell (1993) also from NUI Galway.
The volume starts with a background discussion of Irish Bronze Age pottery and a
literature review of past work. It explains the radiocarbon dating process and defines
terminology. In theory this is no bad thing as the poor humble Food Vessel and its
variants have been subject to a number of fairly arbitrary name changes over the
last quarter century. Thus Vase and Bowl Food Vessels, Enlarged Food Vessels and
Encrusted Urns have become vases, food vases, bowls, bowl food vessels, food urns,
food vessel urns, vase urns and food vessel urns with plastic decoration. Mercifully
Collared Urns are still Collared Urns (for the time being at least) except, of course,
when they are Cordoned Urns. It is little wonder that Bronze Age pottery studies
are being avoided by many of the new generation of archaeologists when the older
generation will insist on such needless re-branding: The term Food Vessel has served
us well and rather like other meaningless archaeological terms (such as ‘henge’,
Carp’s Tongue etc) at least it is a label to which we can relate as Brindley points
out early in the introduction.
Brindley claims to adopt a rigorous approach to her use of radiocarbon dates and
to a large degree she does, however, there are some questionable practices. For
example, when an urn contains the remains of more than one individual (for example
5 individuals at Knockroe) she claims that ‘a single date on carbonate from any
one of the individuals may be considered as dating the entire deposit and associated
finds’ (p17). Given the increasing evidence for the curation of artefacts and indeed
human remains in later Neolithic and Bronze Age Britain, this is a dangerous assumption
and strikes me as an opportunity missed when it comes to gaining a fuller picture
of early Bronze Age funerary practices.
The major part of the book (part II) presents an illustrated catalogue of pottery
and associated dates by vessel type. What is at once obvious from this catalogue
is the paucity of associated grave goods in Irish burials. The ground floor of the
national Museum of Ireland is comparable to a Piccadilly arcade in terms of the
glint of gold and later in the Bronze Age some Irish metalwork is truly spectacular.
But it was not being deposited in graves. Other than ceramics, the Irish burial
record is indeed impoverished by British and European standards and it is therefore
easy to understand why the Irish material has not been subjected to the same degree
of rigorous typo-chronologies as have, for example, British Beakers. The radiocarbon
dates are presented in a fairly balanced and unprejudiced way and so the foundations
are laid for part III which looks at the typo-chronology of the various traditions
and types.
The paucity of artefacts in Irish Early Bronze Age graves is compensated by the
level of decoration on some of the pots. These are arguably some of the most aesthetically
pleasing pots of British and Irish prehistory with intricate decorative motifs combined
with a limited range of techniques to give an almost limitless range of decorative
schemes: many pots may be similar but no two are identical. Indeed, as with comb-decorated
Beakers, this may be important and increase the ‘value’ and symbolism of the ceramics
within their contemporary society.
Each of the vessel types appears to have a three-stage development according to
Brindley. Stage 1 bowls for example are characterised by comb impressed decoration
in horizontal bands. Stage two sees the development of filled motifs and the beginnings
of the use of the techniques of incision or grooving. Stage 3 bowls have more open
decoration and utilise comb, incision and whipped cord techniques. This is clearly
an inadequate paraphrase of Brindley’s more complex argument but the decorative
basis of the subdivisions remind the reviewer of many schemes for British Beakers.
Vases are also seen as having a three-stage development. Stage 1 comprises simple
rimmed globular or biconical vases with zoned or linear decorative motifs composed
chiefly of short lines. Stage 2 sees the development of the neck and shoulder and
the increased use of triangular motifs executed in a variety of incised, comb and
stamped techniques. Stage 3 again comprises necked vessels with more open decoration
but still zoned. Once again this is a crude inadequate paraphrasing of a more complex
typology. But again it has Beaker reminiscences, particularly with those vessels
on the periphery of the main Beaker distribution such as those from western and
northern Scotland. Indeed the extended necked form of many Irish Vases and the use
not just of comb impressions but also the broad zoned and geometric motifs, particularly
filled chevrons, suggest a closer relationship between Beakers and Irish Food Vessels
than the author acknowledges.
The Vase Urn and Encrusted Urn groups also have three stage divisions as does the
Collared Urn group that closely resembles Burgess’s scheme for British material.
There is clearly a great deal of overlap in the radiocarbon dates for each of the
three stages of Brindley’s schemes and this is somewhat glossed over by the presentation
of the radiocarbon dates by ordering them from earliest to latest in each phase.
A more random presentation of the dates for each style suggests more of an overlap
and each phase seems less chronologically coherent than Brindley suggests.
The final part of the volume, examines Ireland and her Bronze Age neighbours. It
is unfortunate that Brindley uses only the carbonate dates for cremated bone and
ignores many of the other dates for British Bronze Age ceramics. Admittedly many
of these non-cremated bone dates do need careful scrutiny, but surely this is the
place to do just that. Hardly surprisingly the consideration of the Scottish radiocarbon
dates relies heavily on the work by Sheridan (all referenced and acknowledged in
the text) but it does not heed the warning words of Patrick Ashmore (Ashmore et
al. 2000) for some of the older determinations. Welsh and English dates seem very
selective.
There are some annoying errors in the text. Thus on p30 and p34 Evans & Megaw 1937
becomes ‘Megaw and Simpson 1937’. On p245 and elsewhere we have mention of spherical
and hemispherical motifs when it is the two-dimensional circle and semi-circle shapes
that are intended. On p163 we have a rejection of the term ‘herringbone’ but Brindley’s
description of the motif seems to refer to interrupted herringbone rather than herringbone
sensu stricto. The adjective ‘metamorphous’ is used instead of the noun metamorphosis
on p323. There are other grammatical errors elsewhere that similarly annoy. On a
purely self-indulgent note, the present reviewer’s observations on Scottish Bronze
Age cups are incorrectly paraphrased on p231: for ‘a large number of vessels’ read
‘ten’. But worst of all, the lack of an index in a data- and site-laden work of
this kind is inexcusable.
Index apart, these other errors are quibbles. Brindley has produced a very valuable
series of datasets and has presented this in a coherent and easily accessible way.
I doubt that it’ll be the final word on Irish Bronze Age pottery, but rather act
as a solid platform and source of reference for future researches.
Alex Gibson
Bradford University
References
Ashmore, P.J., Cook, G.T. & Harkness, D.D., 2000. A Radiocarbon Database for Scottish
Archaeological Samples. Radiocarbon 42(1), 41-8
O Riordain, B. & Waddell, J., 1993. The Funerary Bowls and Vases of the Irish Bronze
Age. Galway: Galway University Press
Waddell, J. 1990. The Bronze Age Burials of Ireland. Galway: Galway University Press
Review Submitted: August 2007
The views expressed in this review are not necessarily those
of the Society or the Reviews Editor.
|